Vancouver: Success story or neoliberal failure?

Vancouver, Canada

Vancouver, Canada

Here’s an interesting article about a city whose allure is legendary – Vancouver. Those mild winters, the spectacular natural setting, the liberal, cosmpolitan leanings and health-conscious lifestyle mean that many of us dream of living there, or why not, snapping up a little pied-a-terre for the holidays. So many have made this dream a reality, in fact, that home-prices and rental-costs in the city have skyrocketed, outpacing the paychecks of many of Vancouver’s residents. Gary Mason’s report on the city’s potentially devastating decline into unaffordability, and all that this entails, is a warning to other cities around the world which could also become victims of their own success. Long-term residents and the professional middle class are being left out in the cold while cities like Vancouver reinvent themselves, selling out to the highest bidders who are often part of the growing (if still miniscule, proportionally speaking) global elite for whom second and third properties abroad, left unoccupied for most of the time, are the new must-have. In this system of unchecked capital speculation, the losers are those who work and live there. But as Mason writes, many are giving up, packing up, and leaving.


A crisis in Vancouver: The lifeblood of the city is leaving

Published Thursday, Feb. 11, 2016

By Gary Mason (The Globe and Mail)

There is a growing societal divide in Vancouver that is threatening its future.

The city is increasingly becoming an investor haven for the rich. Sure, there are some lucky souls, relatively middle-class people who got into the housing market before prices took off and who are now sitting on a gold mine. Most realize how fortunate they are, the lottery ticket they won.

And they have consciences when it comes to the plight of those who have no hope of buying a house of any description in the city.

By now, everyone has a fairly clear picture of what is taking place; the confluence of factors that have led to the moment at which we have arrived; the global influx of capital, largely from China; low interest rates, a low Canadian dollar – all of which has created a price ascension that is beyond most people’s comprehension.

For many young adults, however, the city increasingly represents a place of which they no longer can afford to be a part. Consequently, Vancouver faces an almost existential threat; what happens when the lifeblood of any community, those in their 20s and 30s, decide to leave?

Frustrated over the inability to find even a condo at prices their salaries can accommodate, many young people are saying goodbye. Leaders in the city’s nascent tech sector – the clean, futuristic industry upon which the city is building its economic hopes – are warning that it’s going to be nearly impossible to develop this business into anything meaningful unless the affordability question is addressed.

And if you detect a greater sense of urgency in Mayor Gregor Robertson’s words these days on the housing question, this is why.

Ryan Holmes, founder of Hootsuite, which is headquartered in Vancouver, wrote an op-ed piece recently decrying the dismal state of affairs. “Unaffordability is emptying Vancouver of one of its most valuable assets – young people who grew up in the city and who are invested in it.” He cited as evidence the fact that the city is shuttering many of its elementary schools because of a lack of numbers.

“Vancouver risks becoming an economic ghost town, a city with no viable economy – other than the service industry catering to wealthy residents and tourists,” Mr. Holmes wrote.

Another young tech-sector worker, Saeid Fard, wrote a blog post a while back titled: The Decline of Vancouver. It has been shared thousands of times since it first went up. In it, he, too, laments what he sees emerging. “We have two classes of society forming along a divide that is growingly difficult to cross,” he wrote.

Like Mr. Holmes, Mr. Fard cites the impact the present day reality is having on his field. Eventually as young talent ages and wants the kind of things most people want – a house and a family – many can’t afford to stay in Vancouver. In fact, many can’t afford a home outside the city, either. Consequently, recruiting talent to the city is easy; retaining it is not.

For many young people, the attendant discussion about what forces are responsible for the market madness is irrelevant; all noise. They just know they are the ones dealing with the fallout.

Frankly, I’m not sure many people care about the young and their housing worries. They can find a cheap condo somewhere out in the burbs; start where everyone else starts. That is not an altogether unreasonable response. But think about the implications. A Vancouver that doesn’t have room for young people will quickly become a massive old folks’ home.

There are already enough houses and condos in the city with no lights on because no one actually lives in them. They are investments owned by someone halfway around the world who doesn’t really care about what is going on in the city as long as there is someone to valet his car when he arrives for his two-week stay.

I worry that some people don’t fully understand the danger at hand. Resentment is on the rise; frustration is widespread and palpable. Mr. Robertson knows that if something isn’t done soon to address the growing bitterness and antipathy, his city is not going to be nearly as attractive a place to live as it once was. In fact, in many ways it already isn’t.


One comment on “Vancouver: Success story or neoliberal failure?

  1. Pingback: Divided cities: Equality is a question of moral leadership | URBAN ReTHINK

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on February 14, 2016 by in Economy, Ideas & Issues.

Enter your email address to follow Urban ReThink and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Top Rated

Follow us on Twitter:

Our latest posts

February 2016
« Mar   Mar »

The author

%d bloggers like this: